Knobs or Handles on Kitchen Cabinets: Which is Best?
Cabinet knobs, handles, or edge pulls — the age-old kitchen cabinet debate. Small details like this in the heart of the home can make a big difference, so it’s important to get them right.
If you're struggling to make a decision between knobs, handles, or edge pulls on kitchen cabinets, this article will guide you through the factors that will help you make the right choice.
What are kitchen cabinet knobs?
Kitchen knobs, often referred to as pulls, are small, functional hardware pieces used to open and close cabinet doors, drawers, and other storage units. However, they're not just practical — they come in a wide variety of styles, materials, and designs, allowing you to choose knobs that align with a kitchen's overall look and feel.
The pros and cons of kitchen cabinet knobs
Knobs are commonly used for kitchen cabinets and drawers, but it's important to weigh their advantages and disadvantages when deciding if they suit a particular design.
Pros
Aesthetic variety: Cabinet knobs come in a wide variety of shapes, sizes, and styles, meaning they’re a very versatile option.
Versatility: Due to their small size, cabinet knobs can be used with a wide variety of kitchen cabinet door designs, offering flexibility in style and installation.
Functionality: Cabinet knobs provide a convenient grip for easy cabinet opening and closing, offering smooth daily kitchen operations.
Cons
Limited grip: Some people find it less comfortable to grip and pull on a cabinet knob, especially if it’s particularly small or flat.
Not for all cabinets: Cabinet knobs may not be the best choice for all types of cabinets or drawers, as they might not provide enough leverage for larger or deeper cabinets. This can make them more difficult to open.
Less contemporary: Cabinet knobs are often associated with traditional kitchen styles. If you're going for a very modern or contemporary look, they might not be the best fit.
What are kitchen cabinet handles?
Kitchen handles serve as essential accessories for opening and closing cabinet doors, drawers, and storage units in a kitchen.
The placement of these handles can have a noticeable impact on the overall look of the kitchen cabinetry. Some cabinets have handles centred on their doors, while others have handles positioned near the top or bottom. This variation in placement adds a unique touch to the space’s visual appeal.
The pros and cons of kitchen cabinet handles
Here are some of the perks and drawbacks of handles:
Pros
Easier to grasp: Handles, with their larger grip area, are easier to grasp than cabinet knobs, making them ideal for heavy integrated appliances, especially for those with limited hand mobility.
Modern look: They can lend a sleek, contemporary appearance to your kitchen, depending on the design you choose.
Strength and durability: Handles are generally more robust and capable of withstanding greater force, which can be an advantage for heavy drawers.
Cons
Potential safety hazards: Handles with sharp edges or protrusions pose a risk of catching clothing or causing injury, especially in high-traffic areas or households with children.
Space requirements: Handles require more space, and they can sometimes be inconvenient in small kitchens or on cabinets with tight clearances.
Style limitations: Some kitchen designs may not suit the look of handles, as they can overpower the overall design.
What are kitchen edge pulls?
Unlike traditional cabinet knobs and handles that protrude from the surface, edge pulls are mounted on the edge of a cabinet door or drawer, typically on the top or bottom edge. This creates a sleek, minimalist look and is often used in modern kitchens.
The pros and cons of kitchen edge pulls
Pros
Modern and sleek: Edge pulls offer a clean, minimalist aesthetic that complements modern kitchen designs.
Space-saving: They have a minimal protrusion from the surface, leaving more space for cabinet doors to fully open and for users to move around freely.
Easier cleaning: The lack of protruding hardware makes it easier to clean around the edges of cabinets and drawers.
Cons
Limited grip: Compared to cabinet knobs and handles, edge pulls can offer a smaller gripping surface, potentially making them harder to use, especially for people with limited hand dexterity.
Visibility: Their minimalist design might make them less visible, especially in dimly lit kitchens, potentially leading to difficulty finding the gripping point.
Aesthetic limitations: Edge pulls may not suit all kitchen designs or cabinetry styles, limiting their versatility in achieving desired aesthetics.
Knobs, handles, or edge pulls: Which is best?
When it comes to making the decision between cabinet knobs, handles, and edge pulls, it's not just a matter of practicality, but also a kitchen's design and overall aesthetic. So, think carefully about what kind of atmosphere you want to create.
If you're aiming for a classic and traditional aesthetic, opt for cabinet knobs (pulls); they can be an excellent choice to achieve that timeless appeal.
On the other hand, if you're leaning towards a more modern and contemporary ambiance, handles might be the better choice.
Edge pulls are also a great solution for modern or contemporary spaces because they blend seamlessly into cabinetry.
Joseph Giles offers a range of kitchen hardware designed specifically for architects, interior designers, and contractors. To see our full range of British-made hardware, simply click here or reach out to us for more information.